Judge blocks ICE from civil arrests at New York courthouses

NEW YORK — Federal immigration authorities can’t make civil arrests at New York state courthouses or arrest anyone going there for a proceeding because a policy change was made in an arbitrary and capricious manner, a federal judge ruled Wednesday.

The ruling by Judge Jed S. Rakoff came after New York state and the Brooklyn district attorney sued over the policy switch codified in January 2018. Several immigrant advocates’ groups have sued over the same issue in a case proceeding before another Manhattan judge.

Rakoff struck down a federal directive issued in 2017 and codified in January 2018 that plaintiffs said caused the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency to greatly increase civil immigration arrests in and around New York State courthouses.

Rakoff said the policy was illegal and was made in an arbitrary and capricious manner. He said the policy stemmed from an executive order that did not “compel the agency to undertake its vast broadening of the scope of courthouse arrests.”

And he said the agency, ICE, had failed to explain why its actions were necessary.

A spokesperson for federal lawyers who represented the government declined comment.

Plaintiffs had contended that ICE arrests in courthouses have skyrocketed since President Donald Trump took office, causing what Rakoff described in a December ruling as a rise “by a remarkable 1,700 percent or more.”

In that decision, Rakoff noted that over 500 years ago, the English courts developed a common law privilege against civil arrests on courthouse premises.

“This ancient privilege, incorporated into American law in the early years of our republic by virtually all state and federal courts, has remained largely intact over the centuries,” Rakoff said.

Must Read

Rio authorities step up security after bus...

Aug 10, 2016

Military police in Rio de Janeiro are stepping up security at the Olympics after a bus carrying...

Trump on sidelines as Clinton fills Olympics...

Aug 9, 2016

Clinton is taking advantage of the millions of Americans tuned in to NBC to watch U.S. athletes...

RNC hires strategists to help woo...

Aug 9, 2016

The Republican National Committee has hired three new strategists to help increase its outreach to...

Father of Orlando shooter sighted at Hillary...

Aug 10, 2016

Father of Orlando gay nightclub shooter spotted at Hillary Clinton campaign event in central Florida

Egypt house speaker wants illegal currency...

Aug 10, 2016

Egypt's flagship state newspaper is quoting the country's parliament speaker as saying illegal...

About Us

The Daily Feeder, keep your life updated with the world’s most important political, business, and cultural news 24/7 like no any other news network can.

Subscribe Now!